I think A and D both look pretty professional and I would look at either one of those first for sure. I think the Zesty Paws packaging is very vibrant and might catch my eye first but I like the simplicity of D as well, as it implies confidence in their product.

The orange is eye catching.

A and B both look like brands and a product that I would be willing to give to my dog. He's got an upset stomach for a lot of weird new things, but A and B look like they'd be promising.

A really stands out above the rest. It looks like it is higher quality, and the design of the bottle looks amazing.

The orange gives off a positive, uplifting vibe.

Option A is a bit playful, but also had a serious undertone which I liked. Option D is serious which I liked as this is medicine. Option C is also professional and serious looking, but did not like the overall design as A and D. Option B I did not like the design of at all.

I’ve used Zesty Paws before for my dog so I trust that brand most. I disliked the dark and depressing color on the product for C.

I chose option A. I have used A, B and C of these and had similar results but I usually get the Zesty Paws more easily as they are usually in stock whether I buy them at a pet store or online.

I would probably seek out and purchase the probiotic bites shown in option A. It is the only product that promotes that it has no artificial flavors, synthetic colors, or preservatives.

Yeah, Zesty Paws would likely be my first choice. I like option A. I like the product and the overall product design.

The orange is appealing to me, I like the bright color for a dog health supplement.

I would buy option A because the orange color initially grabs my attention, which then causes me to read the information. From that information I like that it lists the benefits of taking the probiotic bites and I like that it has a list of things it doesn't contain. I also like that it's made in the USA.

The orange packaging really jumps out; the product purpose and benefit are clearly defined.

The orange is very eye catching and with the gut health word that pops out, I already know what the product is about. This option A also looks like a premium product.

I've seen this brand before online and in store. They seem reliable with good reviews. I like how bright and bold the packaging is.

A I like the colors and the design of the jar. B I like the dog and the package style. C I like the dog. The colors are ok. D The image is alright. I don't like the company name.

A is obvious a chew and not a pill that I have to try to shove down their throats.

The orange ones really stand out to me. Really stood out as soon as they all showed up

feels the cleanest and most professional/able to make many different types of supplement with the standardized design so capable, experienced

I like the color of the jar in option A, so that is the one I would be likely to buy.

like the orange color and quality packaging in choice A. It it is not too expensive, it is my favorite.

The design and color scheme in A is simpler. I don't like the beige color in D.

I like the bright and energetic color in my first choice. I also like packaging that is sturdy and easy to open and close.

Option A because the label was the most informative

I like the color and I like the design but also there's a lot of information on the bottle

I would buy option A first because it says bite on it. Option D shows a picture of the bites and I like that. Option B I like the resealable option on the bag. I don't like option C because the title is confusing. I don't know what the pre stands for.

I chose A as I feel like it is a well known brand and has been tested more. I like the packaging better than a pouch or a pop off top. I chose option D second because I feel like it is similar to option A. I also like that option A put multiple uses for the medicine on the forward facing part of the packaging.

I chose A because I have used these treats for my dog before with good results. B was next because I liked the packaging. I chose C next because it's a Pre & Probiotic. D was last because I don't care for the packaging.

I trust Pet Naturals brand more than the others.

The last one is little bit weird the first one I like because of the packaging type and it's a cute dog too. I like the kind that makes less waste than having it in a big plastic tub. Although I do like the design on the orange one I like the ones that say all natural and mean it. I also would prefer to get ones that are made in the USA not just one or two ingredients sourced from the USA or some other BS like that

Option B because it is the only natural option.

I think this zip lock package is easier to travel with and store.

I ranked my choices based on which packaging design made the product looks the most natural. I associate this with health.

Option B and C are first because they look to provide both pre and postbiotic benefits. I like that Option B comes in a resealable bag. Option A is third because it lists that it includes six probiotics.

I really like the 2 options that have the dogs on the front of the label. I have 3 large dogs and I really think they could use some of these. I like the orange that stands out too on option A.

I like b because it indicates that it excludes preservatives

I like C because it was created by vets, so I have confidence it's a good product that's safe for my dog.

I think this looks the cutest. I like seeing the happy and pretty dog. I like seeing it with the woman. The color scheme is also nice and easy to understand the info

It is more helpful and more appealing than the others.

Although I would want to check the benefits and applicability of any of these supplements' ingredients, I like the idea of getting the benefits of both pre- and pro-biotics in one package, so C is my favorite. From there, D has the most trustworthy and clinical presentation, so it is second. B has an eye-catching package, and it suggests that it is safe to give as a daily addition to a dog's diet, which is encouraging, but A's design is just a bit too immature. I start to wonder about the true efficacy of products that resort to this kind of whimsical, playful marketing.

C sounds like a trusted company to me so I would pick them first.

I ranked in the order that I like the packaging design and style and that it tells me trustworthy information about the product.

I would go with option C because to me it looks the most effective and high quality. Option B and A loo kquite polished as well. Option D feels the least compelling to me overall.

C feels like a caring look and color for dogs. A would be my second pick with okay looks. B is too pink. D is overly plain.

Option C was my top choice because I liked the image of the dog and the coloring of the package, which really stood out. Option B was a close second as I actually liked the dog image a little better, but the coloring was too subdued. Option A was too orange and lacking a real image of a dog didn't make it as interesting for me. Option D was my least favorite because I found the abstract drawing of the dog unappealing.

I would buy C because it looks like a better product than the others

I like that D shows an image of the probiotic chew. I would definitely do more research before buying any of these though and would not buy any of them based on the packaging alone.

Option D is the most appealing to me due to the image containing not only the product container but also a couple of the actual chew products as well. My least favorite is Option C because the container/lid doesn't look very appealing to me. I like the container style, as well as the orange and white colors in Option A second best.

I prefer option D. I like the image of the dog on this container. I like the colors and it reminds me of an ice cream carton.

It looks the most professional, as if it was created by vets. I like the information on the front of Option C the most but the packaging looks like an ice cream cup that I get from the freezer section. It should be a screw top jar like Options A and D.