the other one looks made by a computer

I thought option A gave off more of a fall vibe/look.

The other option seems more like Arizona climate

Although Option B isn't realistic since all those cliffs look identical. Option A has the proper vegetation and the cliffs have variety.

While Option B does have the tall sandstone formations that I naturally associate with Utah, the plants in the foreground are just too unrealistic, and they make the whole thing look cartoonish, so I choose A as my preferred option. It is more artfully blurred, which gives it a believable look and feel.

I preffer option A because it has a sunset.

This seems more realistic

A because the image looks more bold and detailed than option B. Option A looks more realistic and fits the passage more than option B

I feel both AI results are good, but A has the edge. I think the use of oranges and reds does a good job to emphasize the seasonal (fall) aspect of the prompt!

A looks more real due to the son. The son in B looks artificial.

you can see more of the sunset in this pic

I think option A achieves the goal the best. I think it look more detailed which makes it look more realistic.

With the prompt of a realistic landscape of the Utah desert at sunset and fall I would choose this one Verse because you get the hint of color like autumn leaves in the image here on the bottom right. Another reason is because of the way the light hits the mountains some of its shaded some of its direct sunset light Its the perfect combination of a sunset on the side of a mountain and I've seen plenty first hand which I am grateful for, option A this one definitely would put me in the mind of it

more inviting and varied less empty space

A looks SLIGHTLY more realistic than B

Both are good but A seems more lush

The colors remind me more of fall than the other choice.

This option featured rosier sunset colors.

This option has more colors of fall

The cliffs/mountains look like what I remember from Zion National Park (in Utah).

it looks too good to be real

Top choice has more subtle details and looks more realistic

The sun glow and atmosphere effects look the most realistic.

I think this image prompts the Fall scene more for me so that is why I choose it over the other one

I really love the details within this picture and all the different colors

Option A does a better job of incorporating fall colors and the Utah desert foliage/landscape at sunset. It's very pretty. Option B almost feels Egyptian in some way....it's similar to some of the Utah desert images I've seen, but not as clear that it's sunset and Fall

This is more in line with expectations since the desert is arid and sunset

Option B shows more of the sun and can see more direction.

This seems more fitting as the mountain cliffs are what I remember when I visited Utah. This seems like a better match as far as geology.

Option B looks a lot more like a landscape in Utah at sunset than option A.

I chose B because it looks more higher quality and reflects it more.

Among these options, Option B AI image reflects the prompt more than option A. Because the golden color of plant is give a real and natural place effect.

I choose option B. because it was looks more realistic and justifies the prompt given to the AI.

ALthough less detailed, there is too much vegetation in A for a desert

Option B because the land was more open

It looks more realistic to me

This one has a texture in the land that looks more realistic and natural, and has more sparse shrubs whereas A has shrubs that look very copy and pasted as well as unnaturally bright colors.

The other one has a river running through it so it doesn't really look like as much of a desert as I think this one is but both are really nice.

Honestly I don't REALLY know what Utah looks like, So I chose based on what my impression of Utah is. So depends if you're going for Utah-vibes or Utah-reality whether you listen to me or not.

They both look very realistic, option B is simpler, but A looks like an image that has been more beautified.

doesnt have water like the other one

I think B reflects the AI prompt more because it shows a scarce and more realistic landscape of the Utah desert.

This looks more realistic

the sunset in "B" makes the difference. that looks like a real, fantastic sunset. "A" is good as well but "B" is better.

B does a better job of showing off a desert. It's instantly recognizable as one and has the desolate appearance you get from imagery of a desert.

Option B seems to reflect as the Utah desert more in my opinion. I have been in the Utah desert many times and option B is something I feel I have actually seen. Option A seems to have too many plants in the image compared to what I have personally experienced in the Utah desert.

I think B looks more realistic so I had to pick that, but honestly A is more visually appealing with its saturated colors and varied textures.

i believe this one does as it actually looks more like a desert with some canyons instead of more mountainous regions

I think that Option B is more representative of the Utah desert due to the style of the plants in the foreground, as well as the mountain structure in the background.

Looks like something I have seen in movies that film in the western United States.. No water makes it look more like a natural landscape